Creamy homemade vanilla ice cream filled with toffee peanuts, honey roasted almonds, and swirls of caramel. A scoopable homemade Caramel Toffee Nut Ice Cream recipe!

I scream, you scream, we all scream for Caramel Toffee Nut Ice Cream!

I’m so excited to be sharing this ice cream recipe with you because this one is the BEST!

Let me prove it to you…

My family (brother’s, sister’s, their families and my parents) all get together once a year for a family reunion weekend where we play games, do silly things and just hang out together.

I was in charge of planning the reunion last year. I wanted to do something a little crazy and fun… of course it had to do with food. 😉

What did I do? I made 6 different kinds of HOMEMADE ice cream and we did a taste-off.

All 6 ice cream flavors are listed below:

• Mint Oreo Ice Cream – mint ice cream with loads of Oreo chunks.
• Lemon Ice Cream – loaded with lemon curd and graham crackers.
• No-Churn Rocky Road Ice Cream – easy, chocolatey and filled with almonds and marshmallows.
• Classic Oreo Ice Cream – classic cookies n’ cream made at home.
• Nutter Butter Ice Cream – for peanut butter and Nutter Butter lovers!
• Caramel Toffee Nut Ice Cream – caramel swirls, toffee peanuts, and honey roasted almond for the nut lovers.

They were all delicious but this Caramel Toffee Nut Ice Cream recipe reigned supreme. By majority vote, it was the winner of the tasting contest. Even my brother-in-law that doesn’t care for nuts loved this ice cream.

HOW DO I MAKE HOMEMADE ICE CREAM?

There are many different ways to make homemade ice cream and some are easier than others. Some methods produce a higher quality ice cream also.

Based on your need and equipment, pick the method that best suits you but for this recipe, I will be using an electric ice cream maker.

METHODS OF MAKING HOMEMADE ICE CREAM INCLUDE:

• Ice Cream Maker — this is my preferred method as it is easy, fast and produces a high quality (low ice crystal and super creamy) ice cream. This method involves a hand-crank or electric machine that spins a canister packed in ice and salt. This electric ice cream maker is similar to the one I use (Nostalgia 4 Quart Ice Cream Maker).
• Bag Method — ice cream mixture is sealed in a bag then placed in a bigger bag with ice and salt. Shaken until firm. This method is fun with kids, low cost but also may take longer. The bag method may become messier but no special equipment is required.
• Jar Method — similar to the bag method, place ice cream recipe in a jar then seal. Place the sealed jar in a larger bag with ice and salt. Shake until ice cream is firm.
• Frozen Ice Cream Bowl — mixers such as KitchenAid have an ice cream maker bowl attachment. The bowl is frozen then put in place of the regular mixing bowl. As the mixer mixes the homemade ice cream mixture, it freezes. No ice or salt required. Note though that the capacity of these is much less (usually only 2 quarts or a half-gallon).

An electric ice cream maker makes it easier and faster to produce good, high-quality homemade ice cream with less effort on your part than the other methods. An electric ice cream maker can be purchased for $25 to $35 on Amazon or Walmart. You can check out the ice cream maker I have here.

For this creamy homemade ice cream recipe, I’d recommend making it in an ice cream maker due to the amount of ice cream this recipe makes. This method also helps the ice cream mixture freeze quicker which can have an impact on the creaminess of the ice cream. I’ll explain why below.

WHY IS IT IMPORTANT TO AVOID ICE CRYSTALS WHEN MAKING OR FREEZING ICE CREAM?

Fewer ice crystals mean creamier ice cream. It’s as simple as that.

Who doesn’t like creamy ice cream, or should I say, who likes icy ice cream? The creamier the better in my opinion. ?

HOW TO AVOID ICE CRYSTALS IN HOMEMADE ICE CREAM?

There are a few things you can do to lessen ice crystals in homemade. To make a more smooth, creamy homemade ice cream use:

1. eggs
2. an electric ice cream maker
3. a deep freezer

EGGS:

To help produce a smooth creamy texture, this Homemade Lemon Ice Cream recipe has eggs in it. Eggs proved color, flavor and lessen the formation of ice crystals (which are all very good things).

I know, you’re probably thinking “Yikes! Eggs in ice cream?”

Yes! 

Check out the section on eggs below to learn more about raw eggs in homemade ice cream.

ELECTRIC ICE CREAM MAKER:

Using an electric ice cream maker proves a smooth creamy texture to this lemon ice cream by speeding up the freezing process during churning.

Using an electric ice cream maker such as this one will help speed up the freezing process. The faster the ice cream freezes, the less time ice crystals have to form.

DEEP FREEZER:

The last step you can take to ensure the best, most creamy homemade caramel toffee nut ice cream — use a deep freezer during the last freezing step.

If you have access to a deep freezer use it. If not, your regular freezer is fine but the faster you can freeze your homemade ice cream the fewer ice crystals it will form. A deep freezer typically maintains a colder temperature than a regular refrigerator freezer. A deep freezer can freeze your ice cream much quicker.

Homemade ice cream can form more or larger ice crystals if these steps aren’t taken.

PRO TIP REMINDER:

To make creamier homemade ice cream use:

1. eggs,
2. an electric ice cream maker to churn and begin the freezing process,
3. a deep freezer to finish the freezing process and lessen the time for ice crystals to form (freezes the ice cream faster).

USING RAW EGGS IN HOMEMADE ICE CREAM RECIPE?

Did you know eggs are used in ice cream, even store-bought ice cream?

The higher quality homemade ice cream recipes, including this caramel toffee nut ice cream recipe, calls for raw eggs. There’s a good reason for that.

I know what you’re thinking… raw eggs though. We add eggs to homemade ice cream recipes because eggs offer color, flavor AND help lessen ice crystal formation (giving the ice cream a smoother more creamy texture and better flavor).

All of those things are good qualities to have in any homemade ice cream.

You can still have good ice cream without eggs but it’s more likely to have a higher amount of ice crystals and be less scoopable.

If you want to make the highest quality of homemade ice cream… add the eggs but before you do, read the rest of this section. You want to make sure you follow safe food practices!

SAFE FOOD HANDLING:

As far as safe food practices go there are a couple of things you should know about using eggs in ice cream.

I suppose you could go with straight-up, regular eggs from the store but you run the risk of salmonella or other food-borne bacteria contaminating your homemade ice cream. Not what we’re going for here.

It’s recommended, when making homemade ice cream, to use a custard method or pasteurized eggs to ensure all bacteria are killed before freezing.

PASTEURIZED EGGS VS CUSTARD METHOD IN ICE CREAM MAKING

PASTEURIZED EGGS METHOD:

I find the easiest method for this homemade caramel toffee nut ice cream is to find pasteurized eggs.

These eggs have been treated with low heat to kill any bacteria and are safe to use in homemade ice cream without cooking or heating. They are a little more expensive than regular eggs but are a time-saving convenience when making this recipe.

CUSTARD METHOD:

If you don’t want to splurge or can’t find pasteurized eggs in your local grocery store (they can be hard to find), you can still make this recipe using the custard method (heat the milk and eggs to 160°F, cool then add the rest of the ingredients and freeze).

This method takes longer but will still give you a delicious high-quality ice cream filled with toffee nuts and caramel swirls.

I’ll leave a note on the recipe card if you choose to use the custard method when you make this homemade caramel toffee nut ice cream recipe.

PRO TIP: For time-saving convenience, use pasteurized raw eggs to make homemade ice cream recipes. It saves you time by not having to heat and cool the ice cream mixture before freezing.

ARE YOU READY TO MAKE THIS ICE CREAM?

Now that I’ve inundated equipped you with all the information you need to make a premium, high-quality homemade ice cream, here’s the full printable recipe. It’s really easy to make and so much better than store-bought!

*This post contains affiliate links.