Crisp hollow golden brown shell filled with creamy vanilla custard-like filling, topped with a simple chocolate ganache. Classic Eclairs dessert that will wow the crowd at your next gathering!
These classic eclairs a great dessert to share anytime. Make ahead. Freeze for later. Enjoy now. Make minis or regular-sized classic eclairs or choose a size in between.
This classic eclairs recipe is simple and simply delicious. Fool-proof if you follow the easy recipe directions and ingredients.
The crowd will be wowed by this scrumptious dessert especially when they find out it’s a homemade fool-proof easy recipe!
HOW TO MAKE CLASSIC ECLAIRS
Eclairs are quite easy to make at home especially if you use this recipe. There are 3 parts to this recipe:
- Crisp golden shells (choux dough)
- Cream filling (my recipe is super easy and delicious!)
- Ganache
CRSIP GOLDEN ELCAIR SHELLS:
CHOUX DOUGH:
Start by heating butter, water, milk, salt and sugar over the stove. Once boiling immediately add the flour and stir vigorously for 1-2 minutes. Keep the heat on (I try to keep it around medium) so additional moisture can be released as the flour cooks.
The mixture will become extremely thick like a firm playdough.
Once the flour is fully incorporated and the dough has been cooked for 1-2 minutes turn off heat and let the dough cool. This step is very important as you can cook the eggs if added to soon. Once the dough reaches 125-135F begin adding the eggs one at a time. Each egg needs to be fully mixed in before adding the next one.
ADD EGGS:
SIZE MATTERS… when it comes to eggs!
When using medium eggs you will most likely need 5 eggs. If using large or XL (Costco eggs) you will only need 4.
This is important to follow as too many eggs will make the dough too soft. It will not hold its shape and you risk too much moisture being retained during baking which can contribute to the shells collapsing, deflating after baking or the shell becoming to dark before it is done baking.
Once the eggs are all incorporated, pour into a piping bag fitted with a large star tip.
PIPE AND BAKE:
Pipe 5-6 inch lines of dough onto a cookie sheet lined with parchment paper. I can usually fit about 16-18 eclairs per sheet. Bake time will be directly related to how large or small you make your eclairs (or cream puffs).
The eclairs will be baked at a higher temperature at first then lowered toward the end. This allows the shell to puff with steam then crisp on the outside. This process helps release moisture from the dough to create that crisp outside and hollow inside.
Let shells cool completely before filling and dipping in chocolate ganache.
CREAM FILLING:
I prefer this semi-homemade, super easy cream filling over a pastry cream because it is smooth, cream, sweet and so easy to make.
Start by mixing the vanilla pudding mix and cold milk together. Set aside until the whipped cream is ready. Next, whip the heavy whipping cream and small amount of powdered sugar until stiff peaks are reached. Carefully fold in pudding mixture. That’s it!
Using a small circle pipping tip or filling tip, pipe cream filling into cooled eclairs.
CHOCOLATE GANACHE:
To make this simple chocolate ganache add 1 part cream to 2 parts chocolate. Melt in the microwave 30 seconds at a time. It usually only takes 30 seconds to a minute to get warm enough.
Start stirring the cream and chocolate using small circles in the center. You will begin to see the cream and chocolate form a thick rich chocolate sauce. Make the circles larger to allow more cream to be mixed in. It may seem like it will never come together but trust the processes and keep stirring.
It will become a shiny, rich chocolate color when it’s ready with no signs of cream or white streaks.
Simply dip the filled eclairs tops into the ganache. Enjoy!
Q & A: CLASSIC ECLAIRS
HOW DO YOU MAKE THE ECLAIR SHELL HOLLOW?
This recipe is really cool and will make a hollow shell as it bakes. It’s magical!
The dough-like mixture is filled with eggs which, while it cooks, creates air pockets as it puffs up. As the dough continues to release moisture during the baking process the outside will become crisp and the inside will become hollow. When the shells are done they will be mostly hollow and ready to fill with delicious cream.
CAN I USE THE SHELL RECIPE TO MAKE CREAM PUFFS?
Yes!
A cream puff is a round ball-shaped shell filled with cream and sprinkled with powdered sugar. Find my recipe post on cream puffs HERE.
You can use this recipe to make your own cream puffs. You can also use the same cream filling. Just omit the chocolate and sprinkle with powdered sugar… you have a delicious cream puff!
We love eclairs but cream puffs are great too. If you plan to serve a crowd, cream puffs are great because they are very “stackable” (no sticky chocolate). You can make them large or small, bite-sized puffs.
Bake time will vary depending on what size eclair or cream puffs you make. This recipe is for 18 large eclairs.
Other sizes you can make. Size of dough line BEFORE baking:
- Large classic eclair: 5-6 inch
- Medium classic eclair: 4-5 inch
- Small classic eclair: 2-3 inch
- Small cream puff: 1- 1 1/2 inch ball
- Large cream puff: 2-inch ball
Other filling options:
- 3-Ingredient Chocolate Mousse like in these Inside Out Eclairs
- Easy Raspberry Mousse
- Mint Mousse
- Easy Lemon Cream like in these Lemon Cream Puffs
- Chocolate Espresso (chocolate pudding with mocha or coffee extract in place of vanilla pudding)
- Lemon Custard (or lemon pudding in place of vanilla in this recipe)
HOW HARD IS IT TO MAKE CHOCOLATE GANACHE?
Chocolate ganache is a simple, elegant touch you can easily add to chocolate desserts like these classic eclairs.
This simple ganache is made from 2 ingredients: cream and chocolate. That’s it!
If you like sweeter chocolate you can use milk chocolate. If you’re a dark chocolate lover, you can use dark chocolate.
WHAT PIPING TIP SHOULD I USE TO MAKE CLASSIC ECLAIRS OR CREAM PUFFS?
You don’t need a piping tip although I would recommend it. You can use a plastic bag with a large 1/2 inch cut in the tip. If using a tip, I’d recommend a plain round piping couplet (the piece you put inside the bag then put the piping tip on and screw a nut to secure the tip), large round size 806 piping tip, A1 piping tip, or a large star size 829 piping tip. When I make eclairs or cream puffs I use a regular round piping couplet.
WHY DID MY ECLAIR SHELL COLLAPSE OR FLATTEN?
It’s frustrating when you pull your beautifully piped éclair shells from the oven only to have them collapse or flatten. If this has happened to you it might be because:
MOISTURE CONTENT
- too much moisture. There are two segments during cooking that the dough will loss or lessen moisture content: during the cooking process of the choux dough (before piping) and during baking. If there is too much moisture during either of these sections the shell may collapse. To avoid having too much moisture in the dough make sure to cook the dough on low for 1-2 minutes after adding the flour.
- too much egg. Make sure to use the right amount/size of eggs. It can make all the difference. Too much egg will make the dough too soft. Steam and moisture releases during the baking process. If there’s too much egg, not only will your shells not look as pleasing or round but they may not be able to release enough moisture to allow the shell to become crisp (add structure that will hold after the steam in side is release upon removing from the oven).
OVENS CAN VARY
- oven temperature is off or inaccurate. It’s always a good idea to check your oven temperature with an external thermometer every once in away to make sure it’s baking at an accurate temperature. If you’re oven is off by 10 or 20 degrees that can effect the eclairs during baking. Too low of a temperature they may not puff as fast or well. Too high of a temperature and they may burn or become too crunchy.
- it baked to long or not long enough. This one goes along with the last. Not all ovens are the same. They can vary quite a bit. I highly recommend checking your oven temperature ever few months to make sure it is actually baking at the temperature you set it to. My mom checked her oven this last Thanksgiving and discovered one of her ovens was off by 15-20 degrees. It’s worth checking every once in a while.
READY TO MAKE YOUR OWN CLASSIC ECLAIRS?
Find the full printable recipe below. ENJOY!
Classic Eclairs
Crisp, golden brown shells filled with creamy vanilla custard-like filling, topped with a simple chocolate ganache.
Ingredients
Shell (Choux dough):
- 1/2 cup water
- 1/2 cup milk
- 1/2 cup butter
- 1/4 teaspoon salt
- 1 teaspoon sugar
- 1 cup flour
- 4 to 5 eggs, one at a time, if using large or XL eggs you may only need 4, if using medium eggs you will need 5, dough should be soft enough to pipe but firm enough to hold it's shape.
Vanilla Cream Filling:
- 1 (3.4oz) vanilla pudding, dry mix
- 1 2/3 cup cold milk, 2% or whole
- 1 1/2 cups heavy whipping cream
- 1/4 cup powdered sugar
Simple Chocolate Ganache:
- 1/2 cups chocolate chips, milk or semi-sweet
- 1/4 cup heavy whipping cream
- 1/4 tsp vanilla, OPTIONAL
Instructions
Eclair Shells (Choux dough):
- In a large saucepan bring to boil, water, milk, butter, salt, and sugar.
- Once the mixture is boiling add flour, and stir vigorously for 1-2 minutes. This helps remove extra moisture and gives the flour time to cook. The batter should turn into a very thick firm playdough consistency.
- Remove from heat. Let cool to 125-135 degrees (hot to the touch but not burning).
- Add eggs, one at a time. Incorporate completely before adding the next egg. Add 4 (large or XL) OR 5 (medium) eggs until the mixture turns into a soft paste that will still hold its shape.
- Using a plastic piping coupler or piping tip of your choice (large opening) and Ziploc bag, immediately pipe paste in the desired size (small- 2-3 inch, medium 4-5 inch, large 5-6 inch, cream puffs- round balls). Bake time will vary depending on size.
- For large eclairs, bake at 425 degrees for 15 minutes then reduce the heat to 375 for 12-20 minutes or until the shell is golden brown and hollow inside. See notes for additional bake times.
- Cool completely.
Vanilla Cream Filling:
- Whisk pudding mix and milk together. Mix 2-3 minutes. Set in fridge until ready to use.
- In a large mixing bowl, whip cream to soft peaks, add powdered sugar. Whip to stiff peaks. Don't over whip or you'll end up with butter.
- Remove pudding from fridge. Stir until smooth. Fold in whipped cream.
- Using a bag with round piping tip, carefully insert tip into cooled shell. Fill slowly until shell is full. You may need to fill from both sides to fill entire shell.
Simple Chocolate Ganache:
- In a microwave-safe bowl, add cream and chocolate chips. Heat 30 seconds at a time, stirring in between, until melted. Usually only takes 30 seconds to 1 minutes. Don't over heat.
- Stir chocolate mixture until cream is fully incorporated into chocolate. Mixture will look rich, smooth and chocolatey when done (1-3 minutes).
- Dip top of each filled eclair into chocolate ganache. Let ganache cool. Store in fridge or freeze for later.
Notes
- Additional cook times:
- For cream puff (about 1 inch round dough) AND small 2-3 inch eclairs bake 425ºF for 10 min then 375ºF for an additional 5-10 min or until hollowed and golden brown.
- For medium 4-5 inch eclairs bake at 425ºF for 12 min then at 375°F for an additional 8-12 minutes or until hollowed and golden brown.
- Best if served fresh but can be frozen for later enjoyment. If frozen, allow eclairs to come to room temperature before enjoying.
Recommended Products
As an Amazon Associate and member of other affiliate programs, I earn from qualifying purchases.
Nutrition Information:
Yield: 18 Serving Size: 1Amount Per Serving: Calories: 530Total Fat: 35gSaturated Fat: 17gTrans Fat: 1gUnsaturated Fat: 15gCholesterol: 142mgSodium: 404mgCarbohydrates: 47gFiber: 2gSugar: 8gProtein: 8g
Originally Published: 01.15.2019 Updated: 03.21.2024
Hi Rachel, I want to try these for my husband’s birthday but I would need to make them gluten free. Do you think GF flour would work or have any tips?
Hi Sarah. I haven’t tied making these gluten-free but I have a friend has. She’s also a recipe developer. She recommends using Cup4Cup gluten Free all purpose flour. I will share the link to her recipe here. It is a cream puff recipe but as you probably already know, cream puffs and eclairs are made from the same dough mixture. One is a small ball and the other a log. I hope it helps. Good luck. https://thereislifeafterwheat.com/2023/04/gluten-free-cream-puffs/
hey! how many eclairs does this recipe make? so excited to try 🙂
About 18 regular size eclairs (about 6-7 inches long after baking). The recipe card also includes some notes on size and bake time if you prefer a smaller version. Have fun and enjoy!
Ingredient list: is it “1 each 3.4 box pudding mix” ? Then the rest of ingredients all have a “1” in front. So is it 1 and 2/3 cup or just 2/3 cup. Sorry, I confuse easily.
Hi Susanne. I’ve updated the recipe card to read “1 (3.4oz) box pudding mix.” Each ingredient in the list is as written. i.e. 1 2/3 meaning one cup plus two-thirds cup to make one and two-thirds cups. I hope this is clear enough. Happy baking.
Hi!
Do we use All purpose flour or self rising flour?
Hi Gina, good question! I use all purpose flour in this recipe.
I used 4 large eggs. Baked the extra time. 1 stayed puffed up and the others flattened. Uggh. Would try again. But do what differently? Thanks
Hi Vivian. I’m sorry to here they flattened. I hope that one tasted amazing! I’ve added a new section to my post with a few things to watch for that can contribute to flattened or collapsed shells. Take a look at those, I think it might help. If I had to guess, I think you would be golden if you warm the mixture for a full two minutes before cooling to add the eggs. I would think there was just a little too much moisture left in the dough. BUT… it might also be your oven. Easy way to check if your oven is baking accurately is to use an external thermometer. I hope this helps. We are actually making eclairs ourselves today.
Hi Rachel,. I have made cream puffs for 30 years. I couldn’t figure out how anyone could have problems because they are soooo easy, then it dawned on me a mistake I made early on. Letting the liquid cool even a tad and the batter is more like pancake batter. Flour MUST be added while boiling. Maybe people are turning it on low as instructed and taking too much time to get flour ready. Maybe you could add to be sure it is boiling when adding flour- then turn down low. Too bad so many people had a hard time. They are actually fool proof if u get that part right. Everyone enjoy!
I make cream puffs all the time and decided to try this recipe . Complete fail. Flat after cooling. I think 5 eggs r to many. Noticed batter was a little thin, but moved forward. Used all the times as directed but these were hard to tell when they were dried out and they were getting pretty brown. I’ll go back to mine
Hi Rene, I’m sorry to hear this. If they puffed then flattened after cooling they weren’t baked long enough. From oven to oven, temperatures can vary. My mom has a double oven in her kitchen. One of the ovens is almost spot on the other is off by almost 30 degrees. Now, I don’t think most ovens will be off this much but it’s always a good idea to check and calibrate occasionally. If the puffs didn’t puff and were flat from the get go then it was probably that extra egg. As a seasoned cream puff maker I would think you could make that judgement of 4 or 5 eggs fairly easily. Maybe check your oven temp and make with 4 eggs instead of 5 next time… or just stick to the recipe you have. This recipe has been tested in my personal kitchen over a dozen times and in family kitchens about the same. The only fails we have had is if the oven temperature is not accurate, we didn’t bake long enough, or that 5 egg is added when it shouldn’t have been (when we made it with Costco XL eggs).
The eclairs turned out perfect! I am taking them to church for a Mother’s Day brunch. Can’t wait to see their faces?
AWESOME! Thanks for sharing Marilee. I hope everyone loved them.
These Eclairs look and sound fabulous. Tell Amy to make them for me!!!
Hahaha! Oh, this made me laugh. I’ll let her know she needs to make them. 😉
My puffs, puff up and are hollow but once they come out the oven they deflate. Any advice?
Hi Angie. Were the puffs golden brown and crisp on the outside? I have experienced this before, it was because they needed a few more minutes in the oven. If the puff was large they will need more time to fully bake through and “dry out” in order to hold the shape. If baked long enough, they should be crisp, hollow, and golden brown. I hope this helps.
I’m trying to make these and they’re not coming out hollow or puffed. ?
Major bummer! I’m sorry to hear this. If they puffed but weren’t totally hollow I’d say they needed a little more time in the oven. but not puffing either?… I’m not sure there. Was your dough really soft (runny) or did it hold it’s shape nicely? If it was really soft and didn’t hold a shape, it could mean there was too much moister in the dough (wasn’t cooked long enough).
Yes, this is happening to me also. They are burning on the top and not hollowing or puffing up.
Batter came out beautifully. But I had major problems with the temperature and cook times. Which I’ve never had with following any recipe. Can’t figure out why.
They would brown too dark and there was so much time left to bake. I just took them out. Any suggestions? I even had them in the middle rack set a bit lower.
Hi Stacey! I’m sorry to hear this. I use an electric oven that has been calibrated to make sure it cooks accurately. I’ve also tested this recipe over a dozen times with no issues. Because ovens can vary the cook time has a wide variency (the second lower temp. time is 12-20 minutes).
When I read your comment, two things came to mind, it may be your oven or maybe the size of the eclairs were too big. I’d calibrate your oven to see if the temp is off. (I calibrated my mom’s ovens a month ago and one was off by 30+ degrees!)
I hope it’s better luck next time. These eclairs are really good!
Hi, your recipe looks great! I’d like to try and made these for an upcoming party but I definitely want to try to make them 2-3 inches long, What might be the recommended baking time for the smaller eclair? Thank you! ?
Hi Michelle! Thanks for stopping by. Eclairs are a fun, delicious treat to have at a party. For a 2-3 inch long shell I would bake at 425 for about 10 minutes then reduce the heat to 375 degrees and bake for an additional 10-12 minutes. Just make sure they are mostly hollow inside when you pull them out. Have fun at the party!
Great recipe. I thought it would take longer than it did to make these. We filled some with pudding and others with whipped cream. Yum!
Thanks, Becky! We love this recipe. It is a fairly quick recipe to make. Did you know you can even make the shells ahead of time, freeze them, then when you’re ready to make them you just pop them in the oven just until they crisp up. It makes for an even fast dessert when you’re in need of one. 🙂 Happy baking!
I’ve made the recipe 2 separate times & batter keeps coming out runny. Help! What am I doing wrong? It’s like soup & wont hold a shape.
Hi, K! I’m so sorry to hear this. Is it “soupy” after you heat the milk, water, butter and add the flour or is it just after you incorporate the eggs? If it’s before I would double check your measurements and make sure you heat the mixture with the flour in it until it looks and feels like playdough. If it’s after you add the eggs I would ask, what size of eggs are you using? You might just need to use one less egg. I hope this helps.