Home » Recipes » Desserts » Candies » Creepy Peanut Butter Eyeballs

Creepy Peanut Butter Eyeballs



With a Reese’s like center and creepy eyeball look, these Peanut Butter Eyeballs are a fast and perfect way to put some spook into your Halloween spread! It takes less than 30 minutes to go from peanut butter to spooky eyeball fun!

Creepy Peanut Butter Eyeballs | Kitchen Cents

How fun are these tasty eyeballs?!  They are perfect for your next Halloween party or spooky night!  They look so creepy but taste delicious.

Did I mention… the centers are filled with yummy Reese’s copycat peanut butter filling.  YUMMMMM!!!!

You can find the full printable recipe HERE, or click the gold button below.

Click for a delicious Recipe | Kitchen Cents

Creepy Peanut Butter Eyeballs | Kitchen Cents

These scrumptious balls of peanut butter love are so quick and easy to make.  Whether you enjoy them yourself or take them as a fun Halloween party treat, you’re sure to bring the spook to the party!  Here’re the supplies I used when making these creepy eyeballs.


Before I show you how I assembled the peanut butter eyeballs here’s how I made the Reese’s like filling.  IT’S SO EASY!  With only 4 ingredients (3 if you consider the peanut ingredients as 1 😉 ): butter, peanut butter, ground peanuts, and powdered sugar, you can’t go wrong.

Peanut butter cup filling

Once they were mixed I formed the peanut butter “dough” into balls.  I used a super tiny scoop to keep them consistent.  It’s a 0.25 oz scoop.  You can find one here if you’re interested.

How to

I stuck the smooth peanut butter balls in the freezer while I gathered the rest of the supplies.  I used Candy Melts because they harden quickly and very hard.  If you’d prefer, you could use regular white chocolate in place of white candy melts.

Here’s how I assembled these fun peanut butter eyeballs.  Once the balls were nice and firm (from getting a chill in the freezer) I stuck on with a toothpick then dipped it into the white chocolate.  I gave it a quick tap or two to release any excess chocolate.  Then I slid the coated ball onto a sheet of waxed paper.  If a hole was left where the toothpick had been I just dapped a little extra chocolate onto it to cover.

dip in chocolate

Before the chocolate coating had hardened I added a little sugar eyeball to the top.  Once hardened I added the red streaks.  The red streaks were just made from red Candy Melts.  I cut a tiny hole in the corner of the bag and piped the red around and down each eyeball.

 red streaks

Once the red streaks had hardened, they were done.  So easy, right?! Even for all the “non-bakers” out there, these are within reach.  I promise!

Creepy Peanut Butter Eyeballs | Kitchen Cents

These eyeballs are so fun and all who see and eat will love them.  Happy spooky treat making ya’ll!

Click for a delicious Recipe | Kitchen Cents

If you’re looking for more fun Halloween treat ideas, check out these “Bloody” Witch Fingers or Full Moon Bat Cookies.  Both recipes are fast, easy, and perfect for Halloween!

Bloody Peanut Butter Cup Witch Fingers | Kitchen Cents Easy 5-Minute Full Moon Oreo Bat Cookies | Kitchen Cents

What’s your favorite Halloween treat (homemade or store bought)?

Click for a delicious Recipe | Kitchen Cents

Creepy Peanut Butter Eyeballs | Kitchen Cents

Creepy Peanut Butter Eyeballs | Kitchen Cents

Click for a delicious Recipe | Kitchen Cents

*This post contains affiliate links. In order to support this blog and continue providing free content, I may receive a commission from purchases you make through the links in this post.  This comes at no cost to you. It just helps me keep the delicious recipes coming. ?

1 thought on “Creepy Peanut Butter Eyeballs”

Leave a Comment

Skip to Recipe